Friday, May 23, 2008

Jail the Righteous ...


No, this is not the slogan of angry atheists trying to reduce the numbers of voting republicans in the coming fall election.  Nor am I advocating we jail anyone who believes themselves to be righteous, which ironically would probably reduce the number of voting republicans in the upcoming fall election.  But I do ask, is everyone in jail guilty of the crimes they were convicted of?  And beyond this why would Christ place such a high value on visiting the sick and imprisoned?

There was a recent story in the news about a man wrongly convicted of rape and murder who spent 12 plus years in prison before DNA evidence proved his innocence.  I wonder, is he the guy I was supposed to be visiting when I went to prison as part of my ‘Christian’ duties?  Should I assume that somewhere out there is another innocent man, and God would like me to drop in on him to ease his burden?  After all when discussing the end-times judgment (or criterion) God thought important on separating the sheep from the goats – His question was did you feed me, did you clothe me, visit me in prison?  I note often He did not ask what I believed in from a doctrinal point of view, but He did ask about what we actually did for those ‘less-fortunate’.

Seems to me the greatest preponderance of those in prison are probably guilty of their crimes.  God would surely know this, so is He really asking me to visit the guilty?  Maybe this about redemption.  Maybe He wants me to bring guilty people the good news of the gospel.  Or perhaps He has a deeper intention in mind for me, after all, what is the difference between me and guy behind bars?  Yes maybe the guy in jail committed the crime he was charged with, how is that different from me.  In the eyes of God, are not I as guilty as the man behind bars?  Has not my sin caused pain and suffering as well?  To God, the guy behind bars is no better or worse than me, we look like brothers to Him.  So is that it?  This is about visiting family, and learning we are all the same in God’s eyes – maybe.  But there might be more.

What is the point of our penal system anyway?  We incarcerate those who commit crimes against us so that they will be unable to repeat their heinous action again.  This forced imprisonment also acts as a punishment to them for doing their evil deed.  We hope it serves as a deterrent to those would-be criminals on the outside to think twice before doing something that might land them in here (but statistics say this deterrent is hardly effective).  We talk about prisons as a place to engender reform.  That is the key isn’t it?  A place to go to unlearn evil behavior and relearn good behavior.  So why is the reform piece of our penal system in such miserable failure?  Recidivism is on the rise, and the argument could be made that prison only trains criminals how to be better criminals, not better citizens.  It seems all our punitive efforts have not resulted in many positive changes from this experience.

And it does not end there.  The idea behind serving your time in prison is that you are in-effect ‘paying’ for your misdeeds.  And though you may serve your entire sentence, your payment is apparently never quite over.  Your criminal record follows you on every job application, or credit application.  Your prospects for meaningful work go down dramatically because of your ‘record.’  If you were convicted of a sex-crime (and let’s remember the story of our innocent friend here, not everyone convicted of a crime did it), you must register as an offender which stigma GREATLY reduces the welcome you get in any living arrangement.  So let’s see, you can’t vote to change anything, can’t run for political office, can’t find work, or a place to live – if you are to survive what option is the one left open to you?  Note that military service might have provided a way out in the past, but in times of war, it is just another virtual death sentence.  Options for survival seem bleak at best, and statistically, we find our punished ones doing more evil and finding themselves back behind bars or worse.

What else could we do to deal with crime?  Take theft for instance, Christ said, if someone steals your coat, offer them your shirt as well.  How radical an approach is that!  Reward errant behavior?!  Give a thief more than even he thought to take, who does that?  What kind of weirdo approach is this?  What message would this send to the thief?  Glad I asked actually … perhaps it would demonstrate way more than any words ever could that someone in this world actually cared about the thief.  It might be the first time in the life of the thief that he gets to experience love and concern for him.  No threats of punishment.  No condemnations of his obviously wrong act.  No question about his guilt.  But in spite of his ugliness we show him unbounded love.  We attempt to meet his need based on what he took.  This kind of singular gesture of love inspires the thief to consider WHY anyone would do such a thing.  Returning love to acts of hate and malice has the most profound effect of getting under the perpetrator’s skin.  It is too hard to understand how love could be returned for hate.  They poke at it.  They prod it.  They test it again, and maybe again.  What’s the deal?  Perhaps this is the only approach that is capable of changing evil behavior.

Have you considered for a minute that this is exactly the approach God is taking with YOU personally?  You were and are guilty of crimes against yourself, those you love, and your creator – but instead of punishment for what you have earned, you get love instead.  Blessed rather than cursed.  Loved in spite of what you do, what you say, all of it.  You deserve to be behind bars, not because you have broken a law the US government setup, not because you might errantly be convicted of breaking a law, simply because your premeditated acts of evil cause pain to everyone you care about.  To protect you and those you love, you should sit in isolation of a jail cell; but that is not how God chooses to teach change in your character.  God reaches out to you in love no matter what your misdeed.  He gets you asking WHY would He do this?  And you test it, you poke it, you prod it, and you marvel at it.  But over time you accept His love, and in that acceptance are the roots of change in your life.  Reformation happens when love enters your life, not when love is removed.

I know we have hardcore evil-doers in our world.  Some seem almost demon possessed in their passion for causing pain to anyone.  Some do enough drugs to be completely out of their minds most of the time while they commit heinous acts.  I don’t advocate we open up the jail doors and let them loose on society.  But maybe we might take a minute and realize even the hardcore criminal needs love as much as we do.  We were ‘commissioned’ to go to prisons, to bring love with us.  Love inspires hope.  Hope can liberate someone bound to sin and give them freedom inside their cell.  Freedom the cancer of evil.  Freedom to reconcile with a loving God right where they are.  Freedom from the guilt of their misdeed, as they come to know the price for their freedom was already paid on a lonely cross 2 thousand years ago.  And when they realize this, and embrace this, we have effectively jailed the righteous.  The state may require its due, but the soul is made free in Christ.  At that point, the guy behind the bars is exactly like the guy who gets to go home after the visit – forgiven.


No comments:

Post a Comment